The Scarce Two Feathers Buffalo Nickels

Buffalo Nickel, 1921 5C 2 Feathers FS-401 (016.633), PCGS MS67. Click image to enlarge.

There are many notable varieties in the Buffalo Nickel series, and among them are the Two Feathers Buffalo Nickels. These coins, identified by the lack of a third feather in the Native American chief’s headdress on the obverse, are one of the more popular varieties sought by collectors. What’s more? Nearly 30 different Two Feathers varieties have been identified to date and are often assembled by date. Additionally, a PCGS Registry Set is dedicated solely to the run of all known Two Feathers nickels discovered to date.

The Story of the Two Feathers Buffalo Nickel

The Two Feathers Buffalo Nickels began like so many other United States coins of the period that are missing an important detail: overzealous die polishing. In the case of the Two Feathers variety, it was die polishing in the area of the third, innermost feather between the back of the Native American chief’s neck and the longest feather in the headdress. The die polishing was likely spurred on by some type of damage to the die, most likely a die clash, which occurs when the obverse and reverse die pair come together without a planchet in between to receive the strike.

The Two Feathers varieties aren’t nearly as widely collected as the more iconic 1936-D 3-1/2 Legged and 1937-D 3-Legged five-cent varieties, also the result of fervent die polishing that obliterated some or nearly all of the bison’s foremost leg as seen on the reverse of certain Buffalo Nickels. But the Two Feathers pieces are nevertheless important varieties in the Buffalo Nickel series, and some have been attributed only in more recent years. This suggests the Two Feathers variety may yet be discovered on other issues.

Collecting Two Feathers Varieties

PCGS presently recognizes 27 distinct Two Feathers varieties on Buffalo Nickels and has assigned most of these an attribution designation of “FS-401.” All such pieces known to date are confined to production from 1913 through 1930, a period eight years shorter than the entire run of the series, which spanned from 1913 through 1938. Some of these varieties are more common than others, particularly in circulated grades. However, in uncirculated grades these pieces are much more challenging. It is safe to suggest that all Two Feathers pieces are categorically scarce to rare. Chief among these rarest of dates include the 1917-S and 1921-S.

All three of the mints that struck the Buffalo Nickel, including those in Philadelphia, Denver, and San Francisco, are represented among the Two Feathers varieties. However, the largest share of these varieties originated from San Francisco, numbering 11. Below is a rundown on the 27 Two Feathers Buffalo Nickels recognized by PCGS:

  • 1913-D Type I 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1913-S Type I 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1915 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1915-D 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1916 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1917 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1917-D 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1917-S 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1918 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1918-S 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1919 2 Feathers
  • 1919-D 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1919-S 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1920 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1920-D 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1920-S 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1921 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1921-S 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1923 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1925-D 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1925-S 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1926-D 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1927-D 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1927-S 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1928-S 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1929-S 2 Feathers FS-401
  • 1930-S 2 Feathers FS-401

All of the coins listed above can be incorporated into the PCGS Buffalo Nickels Two Feathers Complete Variety Set, Circulation Strikes (1913-1930) Registry Set. These coins can also be formally assembled into the much larger, 144-piece Buffalo nickels Complete Variety Set, Circulation Strikes (1913-1938), which includes all 27 Two Feathers varieties acknowledged by PCGS.

Building a Set, Seeking the Scarce Dates

The area or collecting Two Feathers Buffalo Nickels seems to be mainly in the wheelhouse of the diehard series enthusiast. That is not to say there aren’t folks building more basic date-and-mintmark sets that perhaps buy an example or two of the Tow Feathers variety for representative purposes. Still the variety draws its fair share of collectors, as evidenced by activity on the PCGS Set Registry. At present, 15 collectors have dedicated a PCGS Registry Set exclusively toward the Two Feathers variety.

The competition for these pieces is somewhat intense among those who are building related sets, in part because many of the Two Feathers dates offer only a couple dozen encapsulated specimens. Surely more may come along. However, it’s apparent that this niche of collecting, while drawing an impassioned collector base, remains much smaller than, perhaps, for Lincoln Cent varieties or the many hobbyists building sets of Morgan Dollars and Peace Dollars with “VAM”s – varieties listed by silver dollar experts Leroy C. Van Allen and A. George Mallis in their seminal 1971 work, Comprehensive Catalog and Encyclopedia of Morgan & Peace Dollars.

None of the Two Feathers varieties are inexpensive coins. This owes in large part to their overall scarceness, and perhaps moreso to the fact that these coins are generally rare in the higher grades. Most specimens cost hundreds, even thousands of dollars apiece. While comprising a set of coins numbering just 27 pieces, between sheer expense and difficulty in tracking down specimens one could spend many years building an assemblage that is complete – or, “complete” as far as collectors and numismatic experts know to date. The real possibility that more of these varieties may be discovered down the line keeps many collectors who have “finished” these collections fresh in the game and looking for other such varieties.

  • Fivaz, Bill and J.T. Stanton. Cherrypickers’ Guide to Rare Die Varieties of United States Coins. Whitman Publishing, 2009.
  • Flynn, Kevin, Ron Pope, and John Wexler. The Authoritative Reference on Buffalo Nickels.Zyrus Press, 2007.
  • Lange, David W. The Complete Guide to Buffalo Nickels. DLRC Press, 2000.

Source: PCGS

2 thoughts on “The Scarce Two Feathers Buffalo Nickels”

  1. There are a total of 27 different two feathers dates listed in my book but only 20 of which I consider to be “true” two feathers dates, as the other seven show a noticeable remnant of the third feather even tho they have been attributed as such by the major certification services. These dates are as follows:

    01 1913-D Var One
    02 1913-S Var One
    03 1915
    04 1915-D
    05 1916
    06 1916-S
    07 1917
    08 1917-S
    09 1918
    10 1918-S
    11 1919
    12 1919-D
    13 1920
    14 1920-S
    15 1921
    16 1921-S
    17 1923
    18 1925-S
    19 1926-D
    20 1930-S

    1. Hi, I bought today 1916 S buffalo that I believe has no third feather or I would say it has a small mark where the feather would normally be. There is no 2 f variety on PCGS for 1916 S. How could I validate the one I have?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *