Some info from coin facts.
For the past 50 years or so, the 1918/7-D Buffalo nickel has been justifiably recognized as one of the most important 20th Century numismatic rarities. This bold overdate is rare in circulated grades, very rare in Mint State and almost impossible to find in Gem condition. The 1918/7-D is certainly the rarest coin in the Buffalo nickel series (excluding some more recently discovered varieties) and it is one of the most important coins of the 20th Century. This issue is usually fairly well struck. The rare Mint State coin usually has decent luster. Note that all genuine 1918/7-D nickels have a mintmark that tilts to the left.
"WHO KNOWS ABOUT THIS?
545. 1918 over 17 D mint nickle!!!(sic.) Mint
The seven shows on top as well as the lower rounded part of it. I have looked over 8000 other pieces but have not found another.
The mint as well as many collectors of whom I inquired do not know anything about it – never saw one!"
While Lange did not offer another of these coins, Syracuse, New York Dealer Barney Bluestone did offer Mint State examples in four of his first 15 auctions starting with his first auction in October, 1931; the last appeared in September, 1934. If these were all different coins it might indicate that the first group of this rarity showed up in small numbers in upstate New York.
I am only aware of one other example, another Mint State specimen, being offered at auction in the 1930’s it was offered in 1937 by dealer M.H. Bolender of Orangeville, IL. After this Mint State examples become few and far between. Most of the specimens do not start showing up at auctions until the 1940’s and these are almost always lower than Mint State.
Currently Mint State examples of the 1918/7-D Nickel are very rare. In Gem condition (MS65 and better), this is an extremely rare coin.
For years the 1918/7-D Nickel was considered the rarest and the most valuable of the Buffalo series however in recent years the 1916 Doubled Die Obverse has taken it's place. Remember it was some thirteen years after its issue before the 1918/7-D became known and collected, while the 1916 was not actively collected or known until some fifty years or more after its issue.
Here's the first reference I could find on the 1918-D 8/7 5c. I can remember the "Red Book" listing of the variety in the 15th edition, when I first started collecting in 1961, where it was unpriced above the grade of XF. A coin in that grade was priced at $750.
I used to cherrypick these frequently back in the early to mid sixties and occasionally online up until about five years ago. The best was a VF I paid $8 for back around 1964. How anyone can miss the variety is a mystery to me but according to my records I cherried a total of 17 over the years.
The 1918-D 8/7 had a full die run and more, probably in excess of 100,000 as evidenced by this near terminal die state coin-
I used to cherrypick these frequently back in the early to mid sixties and occasionally online up until about five years ago. The best was a VF I paid $8 for back around 1964. How anyone can miss the variety is a mystery to me but according to my records I cherried a total of 17 over the years.
That’s one impressive cherry pick! I highly doubt that would be possible these days. Did you end up getting all of them slabbed?
I sold nearly all long before the days of slabbing. A few of the later ones I did get slabbed. All were AG-VG with weak to very weak dates. The under digit is easily visible even on these.
This is the G04-CAC I picked up a few months ago. I love that you can see the overdate without a loupe. Feels a bit under graded.
https://buffalonickelclub.org/virtual-coin-show/
Here is the latest 1918-D 8/7 die state I've seen. This is near terminal and would indicate that this overdate variety had a full die run and more, probably in excess of 100,000 coins.
